Tour du Danger: King’s Cross

The Tour du Danger attracted such a massive crowd that in the end it was useless in terms of looking at how the junctions are designed, how people behave on them, and how they might be improved. If you were in the middle of the pack of hundreds of people on bicycles, you wouldn’t even have seen a motorist, let alone have been able to observe their natural behaviour in the wild.

So I thought I’d interrupt the Sunday theme of pleasant quiet videos from the Netherlands with a new theme of nasty noisy videos of London’s (and perhaps beyond London) most dangerous road layouts, as part of the evidence-gathering for the Tour du Danger Dodgy Junctions Dossier — the report to representatives on the ride and the problems with the junctions we visited.

I went to King’s Cross and got a wide-angle of the two eastbound lanes heading onto Pentonville Road, and the five(!) lanes at the top of Grays Inn Road, which split into to two northbound onto York Way and three westbound onto Euston Road (which you have to migrate across if you want to get to York Way):

With a close up looking east at the two lanes of Pentonville Road, with the northbound York Way traffic crossing from right to left:

And a look back at the two-lanes turning into York Way:

The Grays Inn Road to York Way route is an interesting one. There are two lanes leading up to the lights. An advance stop box is provided for cyclists — built to the British standard that puts cyclists who use them in an HGV driver’s blind spot. But the entry to York Way is then relatively narrow, with no lane markings. That shouldn’t be a problem — it’s still wide enough for two vehicles, even if one is a bus or HGV. But the way drivers use it is a problem, treating the traffic lights like the opening of a race, and then running into trouble where the road gets narrow.

And perhaps what the Streetview of the junction is showing is that any bicycle user uncomfortable with “taking the lane” at the front of this race will get squeezed out of it altogether.

Motorists are not supposed to go faster than 30 mph here, but they do, racing and stopping in waves. Motorists are not supposed to turn right from Grays Inn Road to Pentonville Road because there is a pedestrian crossing in Petonville Road which matches the phases of the GIR-York Way traffic — there are more than enough signs, but they do it, honking horns at the pedestrians as they go. Motorists are not supposed to race off when a red light turns amber, or race through as an amber light is turning red, but they do it, causing, if they’re lucky, one stream or the other to brake hard.

There are plans to remove the left-turn lane from Euston Road to York Way* (left, in the Streetview image), and the traffic island with it, having instead more pavement outside the station, and a wider entry into York Way, which will no doubt solve some problems and introduce a whole bunch of new ones. Because the problems here for people on foot and on bicycles are bigger than moving around the street furniture.

In that sense, Peter Hendy and Boris Johnson are right. “Physical streetworks” at junctions like these won’t do a vast amount to help cyclists if your idea of physical streetworks is a minor rearrangement of the furniture with some crap cycle facilities painted on at the sides. But nor will “educating HGV drivers”. The drivers at King’s Cross know that they’re not supposed to go faster than 30, stop beyond the stop lines, park on the bus stops, drive into the box junctions before the exits are clear, race through amber lights, turn right at a “no right turns” sign, take drugs, or drive with defective vision or defective tires or no insurance. It’s not for want of training that a great many go ahead and do those things anyway.

Nothing that Boris Johnson is capable of imagining will fix King’s Cross, because Boris Johnson is incapable of imagining any solution that isn’t simple enough to be easily implemented in time for his next election campaign and given a “Boris” PR moniker to be popularised by the Standard.

King’s Cross is difficult for bicycle users to avoid, not because there’s a lack of (sometimes slow, winding, difficult to find and follow, and therefore unattractive) alternative routes, but because, in addition to being a complex transport route through which planners have tried to stuff as many cars and trucks as possible, it’s supposed to be a place. Despite the traffic making it a very unattractive place, with rows of difficult to reach shabby, closed-down and derelict shops and businesses, it’s still the location of two of London’s major commuter, intercity, and international railway termini, one of its busiest tube stations, and a bunch of big employers. People ride bicycles there because there are things to ride their bicycle to. Any fix for King’s Cross has to acknowledge the scale of the damage the motor traffic does to the place, and it has to acknowledge that some of that traffic has to go away, not simply get rearranged in the street space. Back street cycle bypass routes, helpful though they are for some people and some journeys in the absence of anything better, can not be the solution to a place, a centre of employment and services, being dominated by deadly traffic streams.

Roads like this really need rebuilding completely with people on foot and on bicycle in mind, designed from scratch as places rather than as high speed and high volume motor routes. Not merely this one bit of junction, but the whole network of the Euston Road and King’s Cross one-way system.  (Not that the system being one-way is itself the problem, or that merely making the roads two-way would fix anything — the streets of the old Picadilly system are little better with two-way traffic. Making a good environment for people, and routes that are attractive for cycling, can be entirely independent of whether motor traffic is one-way or two-way. What matters is that motor traffic does not dominate and there is quality dedicated space for cycling; one-way motor traffic might even help achieve that if done right.) I don’t suppose Boris or Hendy are capable of imagining the scale of the change that places like Kings Cross need.

Do you have anecdotes or observations of King’s Cross that might inform the Dodgy Junctions Dossier?

* The diagram of the changes in that post might need a pinch of salt — I think it exaggerates the pedestrian space and it even shows a bike lane where I remember there being a bus lane.

About these ads

4 responses to “Tour du Danger: King’s Cross

  1. Pingback: The Tour Du Danger | As Easy As Riding A Bike

  2. oh, man, that two-stage pedestrian crossing of York Road is ridiculous. All the crossings around there are at least two stages, but that one is annoying. Same as the one next to St Pancras (the one that’s part of the bike route from Camden)

  3. As this is part of the Ring Road which skirts the edge of the Congestion Charge Zone, I occasionally drive this route if I’m getting from East London to the other side of town. Even protected inside a vehicle, this is a terrifying junction – Coming round from the east, there are 2 bus lanes + 3 ordinary lanes with random cars parked either side, and traffic vying for lane position while dodging HGV’s and lane-changing buses. Then a blind right turn opposite King’s X station which, if you’re not careful, leaves you in the wrong lane and having to somehow get back into the westbound flow, at which point there’s only one lane for normal traffic… Or if you’re heading up York Way, you’re dodging jaywalking pedestrians and buses pulling away from the bus stops next to the station… so even for a driver, this is particularly stressful. For pedestrians : the multiple crossings, the noise and air pollution really say “Welcome to London” to national and international arrivals at the 2 stations. For cyclists ? Well, the Ghost Bike to Deep Lee says it all – I wouldn’t dream of cycling in this area, even though I’m a fairly confident and capable cyclist, have held a clean driving license for nearly 30 years, and certainly ride ‘with my wits about me.’
    I’m happy to have my comments passed on to TfL with your report.
    Cheers
    MarkE14

  4. I used to take the tube to Kings X, then cross York way and go up Pentonville Road to take my son to nursery. The pedestrian crossing is ridiculously busy, what with large employers and three railway stations nearby, and the island in the middle very tiny. As a pedestrian with a pushchair it was scary to be stuck on there waiting for traffic to stop while being pushed in the back by people in a hurry, or beginning to cross but not being sure I could find space on the island before cars and scooters start racing across the junction. In the end I was so worried for my kid I would get off at Baker street (Jubilee user) and take a bus the rest of the way.
    Now I am cycling to work (near Kings Place) I do a bit of Euston Road then take a left on York way. Still terrifying, but I don’t have the kid with me so I bear with it. The problems you have coming this way are buses pulling in/out of the station bus stops, many lorries turning left on York way towards the redevelopment area, other vehicles racing to be first at the lights to Pentonville road, and cabs weaving in traffic turning left to St Pancras or on to York way. As soon as you’re past the lights there are many taxis dropping off passengers, in an area that is, as far as I can tell, double red lines the whole way to the bus stops. There are often police in front of Kings X, but I have never seen them ticketing this illegal behaviour (look on Google Streetview, you can see three taxis parked on clearly marked double red). Many times I have been overtaken by a cab at the lights (dangerous!) only to have him cut me up and brake to drop off his charges at Kings X. Many users do not respect the red lights there, not even pedestrians, I nearly hit a couple every week even though I always ring my bell going through the light.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s