“Shared” space on Exhibition Road

The “shared space” streetscape at Exhibition Road in South Kensington is taking shape. I’ve written before expressing skepticism about shared space — the idea that removing the road signs and kerb stones is enough to tame the motor vehicle, make drivers slow down and look out for others, and reclaims the streets for people. Exhibition Road doesn’t make me any more hopeful.

The new layout and surfaces might make for a more liveable area, where everybody takes to their family out in cargo bikes and sits around socialising on the stone ledges.

But it might just result in more of the same: large volumes of fast moving motor vehicles dominating the street.

Despite the deterrent of the road works, there were dozens of vehicles per minute coming through here on wednesday afternoon. Hard to imagine that they won’t dominate the space, pushing the pedestrians to the side — and, indeed, judging from all of the temporary signs that are in place during the construction work, pedestrians and vehicles aren’t yet trusted to get along without a little help.

Nor are motorists even expected to work out how to handle a junction on their own — they still require a subtle roundabout.

Perhaps it is unfair to judge “shared space” by Exhibition Road, given that, having taken out of the kerb stones, they have installed, er, bollards: clearly the designers of the street don’t really believe in the shared space idea themselves. Vehicles belong on one side of the bollards, pedestrians on the other, and people can’t be trusted to work that out by themselves. Same old street, different paving stones.

Plenty of free parking outside the museums.

Health and safety in the workplace demands that traffic is kept away from the workmen who fetch fresh concrete. No such luck for the people for whom the finished Exhibition Road will be a workplace.

Taxi drivers might learn to “share” the full extent of the road space, but will the tourists on foot be so bold?

Old habits die hard: crossing Cromwell Road, part of the TfL Road Network, will be by staggered light-controlled crossing, complete with a lovely new pedestrian cage.

And even the lesser Thurloe Place will break the “shared space” with a set of traffic lights and tarmac.

Finally, Thurloe Street outside South Kensington Station, has been made no-through (the old one-way system around Thurloe Street and Thurloe Place replaced with a simple two-way Thurloe Place). Again with the use of bollards to mark a footway because the motorists can’t be trusted to behave themselves. It’s nice, except that with no kerb and no signs at the end, it’s not at all obvious whether or not this is supposed to be a through route for bicycle users.

It does look nicer than it did, at least, in the bits where the vehicles haven’t yet returned. But I’m not sure it looks thirty million pounds better. We’ll see whether it works better than it did…

More about the project on the borough website, and also coverage this week on Zelo Street.

Advertisements

5 responses to ““Shared” space on Exhibition Road

  1. Anecdotally, a lot of the benefit in the UK comes when schemes are new- drivers are unfamiliar with the layout and slow down & become more cautious. Once they’re used to it, they go back to bullying everyone else out of the way.

    Without meaningful enforcement of the 20mph limit, and a rebuttable presumption of fault should a vehicle hit a pedestrian, I don’t see these improving things. I hope I’m wrong.

  2. The naivete of the concept of sharing with bullies. Bullies bully, that’s what they do. I agree with what JtM said, without some means of levelling the playing-field, the bullies will soon resume bullying as before. At the moment we have the cult of the sacred driving licence, where drivers can claim hardship and remain driving legally with 36 points, when 12 points technically means losing their licence. Currently, drivers can do what they like and should they kill or maim, they are at most only likely to get a slap on the wrist and they get to carry-on driving. However, add strict liability; relentless enforcement, effective CCTV and punish misbehaviour with lengthy or permanent driving bans and heavy fines and imprisonment. Then it might have a chance of working.

    I can only conclude that the people who dreamed-up these half-baked ideas are idiots.

  3. Only £30m? I’ll be over to try out that pedestrian cage ASAP …

  4. “shared space — the idea that removing the road signs and kerb stones is enough to tame the motor vehicle, make drivers slow down and look out for others, and reclaims the streets for people”

    Is this some new definition of Shared Space that I am unaware of?

  5. Pingback: Rolling back shared space in the East End | At War With The Motorist

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s